Chartered Institute of Building Magazine of the Chartered Institute of Building
CM NEWSLETTER

Victory for firm in fight against paying training levy

A lawyer representing a firm who successfully appealed against paying the construction training levy is predicting that the outcome will encourage other companies to fight against paying the annual charge.

The levy is applied to all liable employers by the CITB-Construction Skills, based on their size. However the legislation  defining the types of businesses that are legally obliged to pay the levy, is far from clear cut said Stuart Thwaites, a senior associate at Midlands law firm, Wright Hassall.

Wright Hassall lodged an appeal on behalf of a multi-national client which supplies and installs shelving and display furniture for supermarkets as they felt its operations fell outside the definition and objected to paying the levy.

The client, who does not want to be identified, had been asked to pay £85,000 per annum.

“This is a very significant outcome because it demonstrates the extent to which there is a ‘grey area’ in the legislation that goes with this levy,” said Mr Thwaites.

“In the first instance this particular client was told they were not subject to the levy but a year later they were, leaving them with no option but either to pay the levy year on year, or appeal.

“We spent a year putting a number of submissions together in order to argue that the CITB should accept that this company is not subject to the levy.

“Everyone involved was delighted with the result as it will represent a major year-on-year saving.

“This is a very rare result and as this form of case is not generally published in law reports I think it is important that other businesses are made aware of this.”

“Main contractors and other businesses that are clearly involved in ‘constructing’ buildings and infrastructure would be hard pressed to argue against the levy,” added Mr Thwaites.

“But there are many ancillary businesses, particularly those in the interior fittings industry, where applying the definition is not so clear cut.

“Given the cost of paying the levy can run to many tens of thousands of pounds, any company that falls into this grey area would do well to consider challenging their obligation to pay.

"The CITB may have to prepare themselves for an increased number of appeals and the first thing they will need to do is to clear up the legislation and eliminate such grey areas, as well as ensuring that the assessment process is fair.”

CITB- Construction Skills played down the row. A spokesperson said:” It’ s a simple case. The company’s structure and operations changed and it no longer fell within the scope of having to pay the levy.”

Comments

The CITB are crippling SME's with this TAX.
SME's that would normally use any spare cash to invest in the training of staff are not doing so because they have to hand it over to CITB.Thus resulting in NO training being given.

  • 7th May 2014, at 07:38 AM
  • Phil Tate

The CITB, we as small companies should not have to pay, its a rip off, if you don't use the CITB, why should we be bullied into paying "

  • 19th Mar 2017, at 01:27 PM
  • Ian

Leave a comment

News

29 April 2017 How's that! New stand set to wow crowds this summer at Lord's

29 April 2017 New chief executive plans to shake up CCS

29 April 2017 London mayor pulls the plug on Garden Bridge

29 April 2017 H&S inspectors down by a quarter since 2010

27 April 2017 A new look for Construction Manager

27 April 2017 Heathrow boss reveals major offsite plans

27 April 2017 Bouygues to trial trailblazing 3D technology

25 April 2017 In pictures: Crossrail's striking station ceilings

25 April 2017 Emoji are a sign of the times on Dutch building

25 April 2017 O'Rourke appoints first independent chairman

25 April 2017 Multiplex on hiring spree after bumper 2016

25 April 2017 Contractor fined for Francis Crick Institute fatality

25 April 2017 New housing group to build 1,200 homes a year

25 April 2017 HSE consults on independent FFI dispute process

24 April 2017 New CIOB MD seeks to strengthen links with grass roots

24 April 2017 Schools paying thousands for work under PFI deal

24 April 2017 Skanska races to develop concrete robots

24 April 2017 Pair fined £66k each for roof safety breaches

24 April 2017 SNC-Lavalin agrees £2bn Atkins takeover

20 April 2017 Pay strike threatens Hinkley point construction