Chartered Institute of Building Magazine of the Chartered Institute of Building

Public buildings' defects risk fatalities

Many public buildings constructed since 2000 could have potentially lethal problems built in, the Royal Incorporation of Architects in Scotland (RIAS) has warned.

Neil Baxter, RIAS chief executive, said a recent report into the structural failings of 17 Edinburgh schools had highlighted problems that could be replicated in other publicly-funded buildings.

Last week’s 260-page study into the Edinburgh schools fiasco found that inadequate quality supervision on site allowed bricklayers to leave out basic structural units such as wall ties, because their inclusion would slow construction down, at the expense of the contractor’s profitability.

Failings of this type caused the collapse of a wall at Oxgangs Primary School, with no deaths only because of “timing and luck” according to John Cole, the report’s author.

Subsequently, similar issues were found at all the other Edinburgh schools built under PPP (Public Private Partnership) and at recently-constructed schools in Stirlingshire, Glasgow and Lanarkshire.

The RIAS submission to the Cole inquiry was released last night. It highlights a “significant change” in project management over 30 years, which has seen the responsibility for safety and quality assurance in building pass from architects and clerks of works to project managers working on behalf of contractors or developers.

A wall Oxgangs Primary School collapsed last year

Too often these new arrangements, while boosting corporate profits, created public hazards, Baxter claimed.

“In contracts where there is too much emphasis on cost saving, there have been a number of occasions when architects have reported concerns relating to specific building safety and building quality issues,” he said.

A lax attitude to quality and safety, as contractors and developers pursued the highest profit, meant that too often buildings were unsafe, he said.

“If we don’t act on this report, there is a good chance people will die,” Baxter added.

“The system effectively builds in a conflict of interest: the contractor has an interest in terms of ensuring his shareholders are well served by profit, so he minimises cost. This may well be against the long-term interest of the client, the public, the users. This is simply not the best system.”

Willie Watt, president of the RIAS, said: “When major inquiry reports are published there is a tendency for everyone to breathe a sigh of relief, mutter ‘well that’s that dealt with’ and move on.”

He said that was not the case with the Cole inquiry, and the message was simple.

Submissions made to the inquiry by architects, engineers and property managers confirmed the picture of declining standards. An unnamed local authority property director said: “If an architect speaks out [about quality assurance issues] then they risk not getting more work from main contractors.”

Meanwhile, readers of Construction Manager have been adding their voices to the debate with numerous comments on the website.

Bob Brooker MCIOB commented: “Appalling situation all brought about by senior management clients and architects who cut corners to increase productivity and ultimately maximise profit margins.

“I spent 26 years with the MoW and DoE supervising major projects my passion was quality control and in the main good results were the norm, but as far as the abysmal situations on some contracts in this day and age there will be no improvements in quality until contractors, clients and architects give more attention to site control and employ clerks of works as a matter of course.”

While Mike Devine added: “I see poor workmanship all the time in my role as a surveyor who post-inspects work. A big issue is the lack of knowledge on the management side. If you don’t know what it should look like you can’t supervise it adequately.”


Again, no mention on why Building Control didn't identify non compliance with Building Regulations. 1 visit by a competent BCO would have raised the question of why no wall ties. Its time for private Building Control in Scotland before a real tragedy.

  • 17th Feb 2017, at 08:52 AM
  • Michael Mongan

What is the law saying of Project Managers who do not supervise the bricklayer's productions?

  • 17th Feb 2017, at 09:32 AM

I see a lack of quality control in site management deteriorating further as the industry moves away from the tradition of tradesmen moving up through the ranks to become Site Managers and a movement towards university graduates who are now more adept at carrying out all the electronic demands required of Site Managers. They may be qualified and knowledgeable but lack the 'coal face' experience of the time served guys.

  • 17th Feb 2017, at 11:20 AM
  • Steven Palmer

Education is at fault, project managers are exactly that, they are project managers not necessarily technically qualified or competent they just need to know how the project should be run, milestones achieved and gateways passed. Again the construction industry needs to appreciate the professionals and pay them accordingly rather than finding tradesmen earning more money that the staff who are meant to be held responsible for compliance.

  • 20th Feb 2017, at 09:27 AM
  • Duncan Clough

Leave a comment


26 February 2017 Housing association offers offsite expertise to rest of industry

26 February 2017 CIOB mourns passing of 'special' past president Professor Li Shirong

26 February 2017 London firm fined £450k for work at height incident

26 February 2017 Tradesmen sentenced for £300k tax fraud

26 February 2017 Boardman peddles benefits of collaboration at Trimble event

23 February 2017 Drones: when does monitoring become spying?

23 February 2017 Report slams government free schools spending

23 February 2017 T&T appoints Tom Deacon as head of digital

23 February 2017 Talent scale lays bare extent of skills crisis

23 February 2017 Morgan Sindall reports 2016 profit of £44m

23 February 2017 Barratt profits jump on regional strength

23 February 2017 Consultation on future of CITB launched

22 February 2017 Project spotlight: How Reading's Thames Tower was made fit for 21st century

21 February 2017 Galliford Try sets 2% margin in new strategy

21 February 2017 Skanska to trial augmented reality hard hats

21 February 2017 Engineering report reveals 20,000 pa skills shortfall

21 February 2017 EIC calls for new recycling targets post-Brexit

21 February 2017 Plans afoot for Liverpool’s tallest tower

20 February 2017 CITB chief executive: 'I absolutely believe there is a future for us'

20 February 2017 Bovis slows house building to improve quality