Chartered Institute of Building Magazine of the Chartered Institute of Building
CM NEWSLETTER

Leg crush engineering firm fined £277,000

A Canvey Island engineering firm has been fined £277,000 after one of its workers had his leg crushed and later amputated following an accident.

Southend-on-Sea Magistrates’ Court heard that on 10 June 2015 Felix Trefas, a welder for F Brazil Reinforcements, was making large steel reinforcing cages which were moved by overhead travelling cranes.

When one of these cranes broke down, a colleague asked Trefas to climb more than an estimated six metres up the crane supports to reset the controls. While Trefas was resetting the faulty crane, his left leg was crushed when he came into contact with another overhead crane. His leg was later amputated below the knee.

The district judge heard the overhead cranes were poorly maintained so that workers regularly had to work at height to reset them and during the night shift this often involved workers climbing the crane support column.

Summing up he said this “horrific accident should never have happened” and that the company “should have had systems in place” to identify that unsafe access to the cranes was regularly occurring.

The court also heard the toilet and washing facilities for workers were in an extremely poor and dirty condition despite having been the subject of previous enforcement action by HSE.

F Brazil Reinforcements Ltd of Romainville Way, Charfleets Industrial Estate, Canvey Island, pleaded guilty to breaching Section 3(1) of the Health and Safety at Work etc Act 1974, and to two separate breaches of Regulation 4 of the Workplace (Health, Safety and Welfare) Regulations 1992.

It was fined £277,000 in relation to the Section 3(1) charge, a single penalty of £5,000 in relation to the two breaches of Regulation 4, and ordered to pay £11,904 costs and a £120 victim surcharge.

After the hearing, HSE inspector Sue Matthews commented: “It is essential that lifting equipment is properly maintained and that safe systems of work are in place for work at height. Employers have a duty to ensure that welfare facilities are kept clean.

“Felix is incredibly lucky that he was not killed in this incident but he has suffered permanent life-changing injuries. This preventable workplace accident has changed the life of a previously fit and hard-working young man irrevocably.”

Comments

What year are we in?? people must work in these awful conditions poor welfare facilities.
This accident looks like it was only a matter of time before there was a serious accident,this poor chap has to live with life changing injuries for the rest of his life, where are the directors how have they been punished??

  • 15th Feb 2017, at 07:27 PM
  • Denis Lawler

Leave a comment

News

26 February 2017 Housing association offers offsite expertise to rest of industry

26 February 2017 CIOB mourns passing of 'special' past president Professor Li Shirong

26 February 2017 London firm fined £450k for work at height incident

26 February 2017 Tradesmen sentenced for £300k tax fraud

26 February 2017 Boardman peddles benefits of collaboration at Trimble event

23 February 2017 Drones: when does monitoring become spying?

23 February 2017 Report slams government free schools spending

23 February 2017 T&T appoints Tom Deacon as head of digital

23 February 2017 Talent scale lays bare extent of skills crisis

23 February 2017 Morgan Sindall reports 2016 profit of £44m

23 February 2017 Barratt profits jump on regional strength

23 February 2017 Consultation on future of CITB launched

22 February 2017 Project spotlight: How Reading's Thames Tower was made fit for 21st century

21 February 2017 Galliford Try sets 2% margin in new strategy

21 February 2017 Skanska to trial augmented reality hard hats

21 February 2017 Engineering report reveals 20,000 pa skills shortfall

21 February 2017 EIC calls for new recycling targets post-Brexit

21 February 2017 Plans afoot for Liverpool’s tallest tower

20 February 2017 CITB chief executive: 'I absolutely believe there is a future for us'

20 February 2017 Bovis slows house building to improve quality