Chartered Institute of Building Magazine of the Chartered Institute of Building

HMRC bogus self-employment crackdown working

HM Revenue & Customs’ crackdown on bogus self-employed construction workers is paying dividends with revenues falling from tax investigations. Revenue fell 34% last year to £102m, down from £154.2m in 2015.

According to national group of accountants, UHY Hacker Young, this is the lowest level since 2012

and that construction workers converting from self-employed to PAYE is a key driver of HMRC’s yield from investigations into the sector falling so dramatically.

The industry has been a particular target in the past few years, especially surrounding the area of  “disguised employment”, where workers classed as self-employed are treated effectively as employees by construction companies. 

UHY Hacker Young said the recent clampdown may have encouraged more construction companies to convert workers to PAYE to avoid becoming a victim of HMRC’s crackdown on the sector.

A self-employed worker often pays less tax than someone who is on the books of a business as an employee due to tax-free allowances for expenses, while companies are not required to pay costs such as national insurance.

Roy Maugham, tax partner at UHY Hacker Young, said: “The construction industry seems to be getting the message after years of being targeted by the revenue.

“HMRC has long seen much of the self-employment in the sector as simply an artificial way to cut costs. Companies could now have decided to avoid the chance of fines and lengthy investigations by ensuring more workers are paid through PAYE.

“Construction has traditionally had a far higher proportion of self-employed and contracted workers because of its project-by-project nature.

“Moving from job to job also means paperwork errors are far more likely from both the business and the individual.”

He added: “Despite the fall in yield last year, HMRC has been extremely successful in increasing their total revenues as a result of construction industry investigations and have showed no indication of easing the pressure on the industry yet.”


I'd report the firm of architects in London to HMRC that had me working as 'self-employed' for over four years in their office, but I'd likely just end up fined myself.

Not worth it.

It does stick in the throat though, that they pocketed employers NI payments for ski holidays etc., when at the end I had to find another job (outside the UK) as I couldn't afford being underpaid anymore!

  • 17th Feb 2017, at 03:49 PM
  • Kale

Leave a comment


29 March 2017 CM round table asks: Whatever happened to the BIM bang?

29 March 2017 Home buyers get access to Building Control reports

28 March 2017 App allows asbestos to be managed digitally

28 March 2017 FP McCann records profit rise of 55% in 2016

28 March 2017 Bouygues will not deliver Battersea phase 3

28 March 2017 'Smart' gloves warn workers of vibration danger

27 March 2017 O'Rourke fined £800k after Heathrow fatality

27 March 2017 Inquiry after NDA terminates nuclear contract

27 March 2017 Brighton's 'thinnest tower' closes again

27 March 2017 Estates to benefit from £32m announced

27 March 2017 Skanska begins £1m 'big data' project

27 March 2017 Project manager guilty over 2012 window death

23 March 2017 Grand Designs style prefab house launched

23 March 2017 Clients still not buying into BIM, reveals CM survey

23 March 2017 Kier chairman steps down as profits rise

23 March 2017 Plans for four new prisons announced

23 March 2017 Lab to measure fear caused by buildings

23 March 2017 Appliance firm fined £700,000 after fatal fall

21 March 2017 Largest crane in London ready to go to work

21 March 2017 RSHP unveils plans for Hammersmith development