Chartered Institute of Building Magazine of the Chartered Institute of Building

Garden Bridge Trust hits back at Hodge report

The trust responsible for overseeing construction of the Garden Bridge in London has hit back at Margaret Hodge MP’s critical report on the project calling for it to be scrapped.

In a letter to Hodge, the Garden Bridge Trust’s chairman Mervyn Davies accused her of inaccuracies and questioned the validity of some of her conclusions.

Davies – himself a former Labour MP, ex-trade minister and now life Labour peer – wrote that the trust had engaged with communities on the South Bank who would be affected by the bridge’s construction.

Davies also highlighted a survey that had found “over three quarters of Londoners support the bridge being built”, which he claimed Hodge ignored, along with the views of the bridge’s supporters and pledged donors.

Referring to the construction contract, Davies wrote that this had been explained to Hodge during a meeting between her and the trust, and that the document signed with Bouygues “allowed the contractor to engage a larger workforce to ensure all planning conditions were met in the timescale”.

He also said the business plan was a live document and “I am unclear as to why this is not acknowledged in your report”.

Davies said the trust “cannot accept [Hodge’s] recommendation” that the project be scrapped, adding that, “as the mayor has said consistently, ‘the taxpayer will be better off if the bridge is built’”.

He wrote that he believed her conclusion that the project be axed was “based almost entirely on your own opinion and the word of others who have expressed a view, rather than on the word of those with technical expertise in this field”.

Davies concluded his by stating that he found her approach to the report’s publication “discourteous”.

In response, Hodge said in a statement: “I have written, published and submitted my report to the mayor of London. Clearly people will want to comment on the report and I did not expect the Garden Bridge Trust to support the conclusions I came to.

“I conducted an extensive inquiry and the conclusions I reached are grounded in that evidence. My review has found that too many things went wrong in the development and implementation of the Garden Bridge project.

“Value for money for the taxpayer has not been secured, and it would be better for the taxpayer to accept the financial loss of cancelling the project than to risk the potential uncertain additional costs to the public purse if the project proceeds.”

Estimated costs for the bridge have risen to more than £175m and the project has been constantly criticised over its cost, ownership and public access. It dates back to former mayor Boris Johnson, who originally championed it.


Disconcerting that Lord Davies didn't criticise Margaret Hodge's competence or impartiality until she had reported. A number of Garden Bridge board members gave oral evidence to her. His problem is that she didn't agree with him that spending hundreds of millions on a concrete memorial flowerpot was a good idea.

  • 19th Apr 2017, at 06:00 PM
  • sidall999

Leave a comment


27 April 2017 How's that! New stand set to wow crowds this summer at Lord's

27 April 2017 A new look for Construction Manager

27 April 2017 Heathrow boss reveals major offsite plans

27 April 2017 H&S inspectors down by a quarter since 2010

27 April 2017 Bouygues to trial trailblazing 3D technology

25 April 2017 The solution: Morgan Sindall goes round the bend in Slough

25 April 2017 In pictures: Crossrail's striking station ceilings

25 April 2017 Emoji are a sign of the times on Dutch building

25 April 2017 O'Rourke appoints first independent chairman

25 April 2017 Multiplex on hiring spree after bumper 2016

25 April 2017 Contractor fined for Francis Crick Institute fatality

25 April 2017 New housing group to build 1,200 homes a year

25 April 2017 HSE consults on independent FFI dispute process

24 April 2017 New CIOB MD seeks to strengthen links with grass roots

24 April 2017 Schools paying thousands for work under PFI deal

24 April 2017 Skanska races to develop concrete robots

24 April 2017 Pair fined £66k each for roof safety breaches

24 April 2017 SNC-Lavalin agrees £2bn Atkins takeover

20 April 2017 Pay strike threatens Hinkley point construction

20 April 2017 CITB to launch offsite training courses